The Houston Astros, seeking a solution at first base, could find their answer in Cleveland Guardians’ first baseman Josh Naylor, as highlighted by Bleacher Report’s Zachary Rymer. Naylor, who had a strong 2024 season, could be a prime trade target as Cleveland looks to make key roster decisions after a disappointing end to their postseason campaign.
The Guardians’ 2024 season came to a heartbreaking conclusion following a five-game battle with the New York Yankees in the American League Championship Series (ALCS). Despite a competitive run, some of Cleveland’s top players faltered in the postseason, leaving the team with difficult choices ahead of the offseason. Among the pressing matters is determining which players to keep and which to trade, with Naylor’s name at the forefront of trade discussions.
According to Rymer, Naylor could be moved to the Astros, a team in need of stability at first base, particularly if Houston is willing to part with pitching prospects. Cleveland, eyeing pitching talent to bolster their roster, may see this trade as an opportunity to both address their needs and make room for Kyle Manzardo, a young first baseman ready to take over for Naylor. Rymer points out that Naylor is not irreplaceable, especially with Manzardo waiting in the wings and Cleveland’s potential to strengthen their offense via free agency.
Naylor, 27, had an impressive 2024 season, slashing .243/.320/.456 with 31 home runs and 27 doubles, following an even stronger 2023 season where he posted a .308/.354/.489 line. His power and production have steadily improved over the last two years, making him a valuable asset for any team looking to enhance its lineup. The Astros, aiming to revitalize their offense for the 2025 season, could greatly benefit from his presence at first base.
For Houston to acquire Naylor, they would likely need to offer two of their top pitching prospects: right-handers Miguel Ullola and Jose Fleury. Ullola, 22, is seen as a high-potential pitcher with electric stuff, though his command remains an issue. In 2024, he pitched 130.1 innings, allowing 74 hits but walking 77 batters, indicating room for improvement in his control. Fleury, also 22, is praised for his excellent changeup and strong command, but his velocity is in the low 90s, limiting his overall ceiling.
This trade would provide benefits for both teams. The Astros would secure a first baseman in Naylor, who could contribute to their offensive resurgence in 2025. On the other hand, the Guardians would receive two promising pitching prospects, giving them the chance to reinforce their pitching staff. The deal would also clear the way for Manzardo to take over at first base, making it a strategic move for Cleveland as they retool for the future.
As both teams approach the offseason, this potential trade could be a pivotal moment, addressing key needs on both sides. While Houston fills a long-standing void at first base, Cleveland strengthens their pitching depth and makes way for the next generation of talent at first.
